My first view of a buzzard was a memorable one. The bird was dead, lying on its back with wings outstretched and a gin-trap attached to its legs. It had been dumped in the courtyard of the Cornish farm where I was staying and I viewed it from an upstairs window. I was eight years old at the time and the 1954 Protection of Birds Act, which had not only given the buzzard full protection, but also outlawed pole-trapping, was a mere four years old.

Over breakfast I discovered that the farmer, who was well aware that killing buzzards was illegal, had trapped the unfortunate bird. He claimed that buzzards took his lambs. Even to me, as a child, that seemed improbable, and when I came home from that holiday I read everything I could about these birds. It didn’t take me long to discover that buzzards may be guilty of many things, but killing lambs definitely wasn’t one of them.

We never had another family holiday in Cornwall. Instead my parents took us to the Continent, to Germany, France, Austria and Italy. I soon became familiar with live buzzards, for they have always been widespread and common throughout mainland Europe. However, I never saw a buzzard during my childhood in Kent. According to Dr James Harrison’s The Birds of Kent, the buzzard became extinct as a breeding bird in Kent sometime between the end of the 18th and the beginning of the 19th century. After that the only records were of a few migrants in spring and autumn, most seen on the coast.

Buzzards eventually re-established themselves as Kentish breeding birds in the 1990s, with the first confirmed breeding on the North Downs in 1998. The nest was within my home parish and a remarkable number of birdwatchers came to see them, as only 10 years ago they were still a novelty in south-east England.

Not anymore, though. The buzzard’s remarkable spread and recolonisation of southern and eastern England during the past 10 years has been quite astonishing, prompting many unanswered questions. Was it really continued persecution that prevented them moving back east? And what was it that allowed such a rapid colonisation of long-lost ground?

According to the experts, buzzards may now be our most numerous bird of prey, outnumbering the once ubiquitous kestrel. With the resurgence in numbers has come the expected calls from some quarters claiming that it’s high time that they were controlled. I cannot be the only one to have had people tell me that they saw a dozen buzzards walking round a ploughed field or watched a flock of 18 thermalling in the sky. “It’s too many. Something’s got to be done about them!” is a familiar cry.

Why? Yes, they are predators and the list of live prey they will take is a long one, ranging from earthworms to young rabbits, not forgetting a wide variety of birds which includes everything from partridge chicks to pheasant poults. The recent celebrated case of one catching a grey phalarope was widely reported in the press, but if you know anything about buzzards that was hardly surprising. A grey phalarope is a very small bird and by wintering on a Cornish marsh rather than far out in the Atlantic Ocean it was exhibiting aberrant behaviour, making it highly vulnerable to predation. If the buzzard hadn’t got it, something else would have done.

Buzzards are both impressive birds and a natural part of our countryside and calls from the gamekeeping lobby to seek to control their numbers are certain to be extremely bad for the image of shooting. Look at the question from the general public’s point of view. Why do we want to kill buzzards? Because we fear that they might kill our partridges and pheasants. What do we want to do with those partridges and pheasants? Why, kill them, of course. As raptors go, buzzards are both ineffective and relatively inoffensive. If you don’t believe me, ask yourself why no self-respecting falconer is ever seen with a buzzard on his wrist. The impact they have on game interests is low. Numerous West Country shoots have managed to live with high densities of nesting buzzards for years without serious problems.

Enjoy buzzards for what they are: impressive, handsome birds whose presence is to be enjoyed. For most of my life I’ve been denied the pleasure of watching them thermalling high in a summer sky, their plaintive mewing revealing their presence. The fact that they now breed in every English county should be a cause for celebration, not for calls for a change in legislation.80

  • Jeff Douglas

    If the Shooting Times and by implication, the general shooting fraternity is against the DEFRA proposal, surely this daft and immoral idea has come from someone in DEFRA who hasn’t thought the thing through or with a vested interest in the big commercial shoots and hunting estates. Either way it would be an improper use of public money as the death of buzzards or pheasants by whatever method does not impinge on the average taxpayer’s lifestyle one iota – except in the infrequent but joyous sighting of such magnificent birds in the British countryside. Leave them alone DEFRA! Incidently – good recent sightings from train of a buzzard in tree near Charing in Kent.

  • j.stanier

    All the evidence points to the buzzard having minimal impact. Yet again the usual selfish attitudes that give shooting a bad image. Wake up! Too often now we are over managing the countryside and in doing so it becomes less authentic by the day.

  • andrew donkin

    i have witnessed the destruction of buzzards on numerous occasions, i have worked for two estates and have experienced what they can do, something needs to be done to stop these birds getting out of control, the only people who want to keep them in the skys are the peple that no nothing about the impact they can have

  • paul robinson

    buzzards are causing mayhem,i have seen them taking rabbits,they are not carrion eaters,why is it good to see them,they have taken partridges,and god knows what else off my neighbouring fields,why encourage something at the top of the foodchain,only for the demise of other mammals.TOTALLY STUPID

  • T.Manganiello

    indeed beautiful birds but moderation is always being the key word.