Jeremy Hunt says: To me, the stop whistle is an absolutely essential part of gundog training – in fact it should be an essential part of training any dog. Driving a car without brakes is unthinkable and trying to control a dog you can’t stop is also problematic!

I think the concerns expressed to you about overdoing the “stop” command are true to some extent in that any part of training must not be undertaken excessively (even though difficulties may be encountered).

The reason for this is because intelligent dogs start to develop issues when there is constant repetition of one particular stage of training – and then it becomes counter-productive. The harder you try to correct or instil a command because the dog is having a problem with it, the harder it is to teach.

I have seen some very harsh approaches used to achieve the “stop”. They aren’t needed if you tackle it properly. Our youngsters are attentive to the whistle at all times and from a very young age. Even when being allowed loose exercise they learn to look up at the sound of a pip on the whistle.

I will “pip”, hold up a hand when they are just a few yards away, then give a prolonged but positive “sit” command and they soon learn what’s wanted. Once sitting I approach the youngster, praise it and then let it carry on. As the pup develops and we gain a closer bond through training I continue this so I can get a “stop and sit” at a good distance from me.

Suddenly bringing in a heavy-handed attitude to teaching an enthusiastic youngster to stop on a sixpence umpteen yards away from you – and repeatedly doing this – can instil hesitancy in other parts of your training. You may find a dog will start to automatically stop when being sent away on a retrieve because he is anticipating your command.

Related stories

Gundog obedience training

How to buy your first gundog puppy

More gundog training, breeding and health advice