We pitted two models of the Beretta Silver Pigeon Vittoria — field and competition — against each other to compare their performance.
The guns themselves are almost identical in that they are both the well-documented Silver Pigeon actions of which there are hundreds of thousands in circulation. These are among the go- to guns for many shooters with a passion for either game or clays.
We gave both guns an early-morning workout at the shooting school, for which I was joined by two of our instructors. Richard Weller, though an excellent all-round Shot, is not exactly the target market given that he is 6ft 4in and hardly built for ballet. The other was Paul Whitton, again an all-round shooter but a left-hander. I am 6ft and not built for ballet either so it would be an interesting test.
The field version features an auto-safety
Starting with driven targets and a variety of cartridges from 21g to 28g, both guns were easy to shoot despite the issues of fit. As instructors we become used to a wide range of guns and can switch between different configurations without too much difficulty. Both guns handled very well with no vices, the usual excellent Beretta trigger-pulls and both requiring exactly the same pressure. The ejector timing was identical.
The Vitttoria Field has slightly lighter barrels
We left the choke in the guns that they arrived with, which were half and full, and consequently the clays were smoking fairly frequently. We all favoured the Sporter marginally, as the slightly heavier barrel made it a little steadier and smoother to shoot, but none of us is slight of stature.
We then shot a super Sporting style stand with six traps and a variety of targets. Both guns were faultless and performed exceptionally well, in part because we were all able to adapt ourselves to the guns. The recoil was absorbed by a combination of the weight and balance of the guns.
Silver Pigeon 1 Vittoria Field
A female client tries the guns
I conducted a further test later in the day by asking one of my clients, who matches the target market for the Vittoria in terms of height and build, to shoot one of the guns. She already shoots one of the 690 series of guns with a Vittoria stock and chose the competition model due to the stock being slightly different with the adjustable comb.
When she tried shooting the same super Sporting layout, the gun got the thumbs up on all counts. The whole point of the Vittoria is the stock design; at 14in to the mid-point with the standard pad, it is intended to provide comfort for the shorter shooter as the stocks on both guns are this length. The competition version has an adjustable comb and the field version the Monte Carlo-style parallel comb. Which version you might choose depends more on your build than the intended use.
The competition one is more flexible in terms of fitting for bend or drop. The other attribute both stocks have is the rake of the pistol grip that makes it easier for smaller hands to reach the trigger.
Other than the stocks the only other variation between the guns is the field version has a narrow game top rib, solid mid rib with a barrel weight of 1,441g and an auto-safety. The competition version has a vented mid-rib, wider parallel top rib with a centre bead and slightly heavier barrels at 1,459g together with a manual safety catch.
The competition model boasts an comb
We haven’t managed to wear a Silver Pigeon action out at the shooting school; some are decades old and have shot millions of rounds.
The critical issue is, does the stock of the Vittoria suit you in terms of fit? It was originally marketed for female shooters, but many more are better suited to a standard gun, usually after some adjustments.
Proper gun fittings cannot be done in a static environment because you cannot make multiple adjustments to length, drop and cast on a gun off the shelf, then shoot the gun and see if it works for you. You may shoot a gun well with a ‘guess fit’ but probably not as well as if a full fitting has been done and the stock altered accordingly.
Many shooters spend a lot of money changing their gun when they become disillusioned rather than getting their existing gun fitted using a purpose-built try gun at one of the major shooting schools. The schools’ specialist instructors are trained, practised and proficient because they are doing fittings every day of the week.
There are different versions and calibres available in the Vittoria line so do your homework before you part with the cash, including for the fitting. There is also a 28-bore, 32in barrel version, which would be fun to test.
Action and barrels 20/20. The Silver Pigeon is tried and tested
Handling 19/20. These guns do the job exceptionally well
Trigger 20/20. Standard Beretta, always reliable
Stock 19/20. Plain wood but not unattractive
Value 19/20. Both guns will last a lifetime if looked after
Hunt Saboteurs demand five-year jail terms for trail-hunters in manifesto condemned as "morally bankrupt", while Reform pledges to reverse Labour’s ban.
By ShootingUK
Get the latest news delivered direct to your door
Subscribe to Shooting Times & Country
Discover the ultimate companion for field sports enthusiasts with Shooting Times & Country Magazine, the UK’s leading weekly publication that has been at the forefront of shooting culture since 1882. Subscribers gain access to expert tips, comprehensive gear reviews, seasonal advice and a vibrant community of like-minded shooters.
Save on shop price when you subscribe with weekly issues featuring in-depth articles on gundog training, exclusive member offers and access to the digital back issue library. A Shooting Times & Country subscription is more than a magazine, don’t just read about the countryside; immerse yourself in its most authoritative and engaging publication.
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.