Clever birds who are part of folklore, explains Peter Theobald

Few birds divide opinion like the rook. On the one hand we have farmers, who often endure massive damage to crops at certain times of the year, and on the other, the people who love to hear the most quintessentially English bird going about its business.  The background cawing of rooks frequently heralds sinister goings-on in the popular television series Midsomer Murders.

But when it is doing no harm even farmers have a grudging respect for the rook. One gets the feeling that while rooks will certainly take eggs and young birds, they do not actively look for them, unlike other members of the corvid family, such as crows and magpies. Few countrymen have any regard for the latter, while secretly admiring the antics of the former.

Like all corvids, rooks are celebrated for their intelligence and can create tools to solve their problems. In one experiment, a rook was placed next to a test tube half full of water. On the water floated an earthworm, but the water level was too low for the bird to reach it. Some pebbles were made available, and it did not take very long for the rook to work out that if it dropped the pebbles into the test tube, thus raising the water level, the worm would float to the top. Some humans wouldn’t be able to work that out.

Rooks are also a firm part of folklore. Many people believe they bring good luck. It is said that if rooks abandon their communal nest site, a death is imminent. Country people have long thought you can foretell the weather by a rook’s nesting behaviour. If they build their nests high in the trees, you can look forward to a fine summer, but built low in the branches and a summer of wind and rain lies ahead.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Bilberry and Birch (@bilberrybirch) on

A flock of crows or rooks?

How do you tell the difference between a rook and a crow? An old country saying sums it up nicely, “If you see a rook on its own, it is a crow, but if you see a flock of crows, they are rooks.” In addition rooks have a distinctive area of skin round the base of the beak, and crows do not. However, young rooks do not get the area of skin round their beaks until they are around six months old, leading to some confusion, fooling some shooters into believing they are killing crows, when in fact, they are immature rooks. In any case, rooks have a blue sheen to their feathers, quite unlike the black colouring of crows. They also have feathery ‘trousers’.

Sociable birds

Rooks are very sociable birds, nesting in colonies, year after year. Nests are built from twigs broken off branches, rather than from the woodland floor. They also sometimes rob material from neighbouring nests if the owners leave them unguarded. Three to five eggs are laid from early March, hatching after 16 to 18 days, with both parents ferrying food to the growing chicks.


Rooks may be legally shot for crop protection in England and to protect threatened birds

12 May – a crucial date

Youngsters fledge after about 32 days, and it used to be a time of year when everyone who owned a firearm would assemble at the rookery to shoot the young birds before they were strong enough to fly away. Timing was crucial; a few days too soon, and the birds would still be in the nest, a few days too late, and the whole lot would disappear after the first shot. May 12th was the chosen day, and the meat from the shot rooks was to be made into traditional rook pie, enjoyed by the entire village.


Is shooting rooks a crime?

When reader Ian Taylor emailed to say he was being charged with shooting corvids, I couldn’t believe my eyes. Corvids…

rook pie

Rook pie recipe

Rook pie recipe: Top chef Mark prepares a seasonal, no-nonsense dish featuring young rooks in a pie.

Cover crop attacks

My own small wood hosts a small rookery of about 40 nests, but is also a roost for much larger numbers of mixed corvids, up to 1,000 strong. The only time these birds have caused me any kind of grief is when they have attacked the maize cover crops.  I have tried to discourage the roosting, by shooting them coming in, but the rooks have shown their intelligence by starting to arrive in a large flock when it is almost too dark to see. I also don’t want to shoot the strips at a time when I trying to encourage the pheasants into them.

Last word

Natural Resources Wales removed rooks from the general licence in October 2019 stating: ” Findings from the UK Breeding Bird Survey suggest that in Wales rook populations have significantly declined over both the long term (by 60% between 1994-2017) and in the short-term (by 50% between 2007-2017). Due to the significance of this population change, rook will not be included in the new General Licences.”