As Sporting Gun’s Deer Man, Jon Snowdon, will confirm, roe deer have been called all sorts of things by frustrated stalkers at all times of the year!
But seriously, the answer to your question is both yes, and no. It also depends on who you ask and sometimes also on the locality because calling is not only operator-sensitive but also seems to work better in some areas than others.
It is an arcane subject and set about with caveats, ifs, buts and whereases. It is generally accepted that, with care and experience, it is occasionally possible to call a Buck during the rut, either by barking a challenge or by imitating the calls of doe or kid. The kid’s distress call will apparently work occasionally until Christmas or thereabouts, so can be useful during the doe season.
If I sound a little sceptical, I am not alone. Richard Prior, who knows a lot more about deer than anyone else I have ever met, wrote in his wonderful book Modern Roe Stalking: “Books have been written on the art of calling which give precise details of the rhythm, type and duration of each set of calls. Unfortunately the roe have not read these books and so they have no reason to conform to the rules.”
A pinch of salt might just be required! The problem is that, although calling can work, most of us are trying to imitate a call which is very infrequently heard – and if you don’t get it right it alarms deer instead of attracting them.
As a totally incompetent caller I always prefer silence and invisibility to vocalisation, but nothing is cast in stone and deer really don’t like hunters or any other predator sneaking about the woods.
If you really do want to see deer, get a saw and a hammer and nails and start knocking up a ground seat; they will probably come to see what you are up to. Curiosity doesn’t only kill cats!
Similar shooting questions answered:
How far do deer normally run after a heart shot?
Was I right to cull this buck when deer stalking?
When deer stalking what’s the collective term for roe?