Home / Shooting / Rifles / Five of the best sound moderators, from compact to a magnum over-barrel designs

Five of the best sound moderators, from compact to a magnum over-barrel designs

The Shooting Times team picks five sound moderators covering everything from the .17HMR to magnum calibres, chosen on weight, length and claimed performance

Five of the best sound moderators, from compact to a magnum over-barrel designs

Not long ago a sound moderator was something of an afterthought – a heavy steel tube screwed on to the end of a stalking rifle that made it longer, front-heavy and awkward to carry. Today it is fitted almost as a matter of course, and makers are competing hard on weight, length and performance. Over-barrel layouts tuck much of the body back over the barrel, titanium and aluminium keep weight down, and many can be stripped at home for cleaning.

To see where the market stands, we have chosen five models covering everything from the .17HMR to magnum calibres. Remember, a moderator no longer needs to go on your certificate, but you must hold a firearm or shotgun certificate to possess one for a section 1 rifle.

Five sound moderators for rimfire and centrefire rifles

Ase Utra ECOi – £55

The Ase Utra ECOi aluminium rimfire sound moderator with its end cap removed
The ECOi strips easily for cleaning, which matters with dirty rimfire ammunition

Finnish maker Ase Utra has been building sound moderators since 1994, and the ECOi is its answer for the rimfire shooter. It is intended for both rifle and pistol use, with a dedicated .17HMR version alongside the standard model, and comes threaded ½in x 20 UNF or ½in x 28 UNEF.

The body is anodised aluminium, which keeps weight down, and the simple construction means it strips easily for cleaning – no small consideration given how dirty rimfire ammunition runs. Its slim profile, around 28mm across, leaves room for iron sights or a low-mounted scope. Claimed reduction is from roughly 29dB to 33dB on a rifle and from 28dB to 31dB on a pistol, impressive for its size, and Ase Utra says there is no noticeable first-round pop, so the first shot at a rabbit is as quiet as the last. A sensible, no-fuss choice for anyone who does their rabbiting with a .22.

vikingshoot.com

Hausken MD35 Mini – £108

The Hausken MD35 Mini, a short on-barrel sound moderator for rimfire rifles
At 128mm long and 35mm across, the MD35 Mini barely registers on the end of a rimfire

If you want a moderator that barely registers on the end of the barrel, the Hausken MD35 Mini is hard to ignore. It is the shortest and lightest on-barrel model in the Hausken range, measuring just 128mm long and 35mm in diameter, so a rimfire stays handy and fits a standard gun slip. It is offered in two bore sizes, 4.5mm and 5.7mm, covering .17 and .22 rimfire, and there is a dedicated version for small centrefire calibres such as the .223, which widens its appeal to the fox controller.

Claimed sound reduction is 20dB or more. That is more modest than some rivals in this group, and it is the price you pay for its compact dimensions, but for rabbits and squirrels it does the job without adding bulk. Keenly priced, with a proofed version available for the .17, it makes a practical first moderator for a new shot.

gmk.co.uk

Wildcat Panther – £220

The Wildcat Panther over-barrel rimfire sound moderator in black
The Panther’s over-barrel body adds just 98mm at the muzzle

Worcestershire-based Wildcat describes the Panther as its premium rimfire moderator, and the engineering bears that out. It borrows a scaled-down version of the diffuser-style baffle from the company’s larger Evolution model, housed in an aluminium and stainless-steel body. The over-barrel design is the clever part: part of the body sits back over the barrel, so it adds just 98mm at the muzzle end and keeps the balance closer to the hand. It is also strippable, which makes cleaning rimfire fouling a straightforward job.

At 221g and 38mm in diameter it is not the lightest here, but it handles all rimfire calibres plus the .17 and .22 Hornet, making it a useful one-moderator answer for anyone who runs a .22LR and a .22 Hornet side by side. Threads include ½in x 20 UNF, ½in x 28 UNEF and 15×1, and it fits barrels up to 23.5mm. Sold through registered dealers only.

wildcatmoderators.co.uk

Freyr & Devik Featherweight 149 – £330

The Freyr and Devik Featherweight 149 lightweight centrefire sound moderator
A titanium core and aluminium baffles keep the Featherweight 149 to about 149g

The clue is in the name. The Featherweight 149 from Freyr & Devik weighs approximately 149g, which is remarkably light for a centrefire moderator, and at that weight it barely alters the natural balance of the rifle. The Norwegian maker achieves this with a titanium core and thread, which take the blast, and an aluminium baffle stack. The unit is designed to be opened easily, and the maker places emphasis on regular cleaning, so it rewards an owner who looks after it.

It measures 125mm overall, 109mm of that in front of the muzzle, and is 44.5mm across. Claimed reduction is from 27dB to 29dB, a serious figure for something so light. It is pitched at smaller calibres, though versions are listed up to .30 calibre, with ½in x 20 UNF and 14×1 threads. Ideal for the stalker who covers miles on the hill, or on driven hunts with a dog to handle.

clunyguns.co.uk

Stalon XE149 – £380

The Stalon XE149 sound moderator with its telescopic over-barrel rear section
The XE149’s telescopic rear section slides back over the barrel, keeping the weight near the hands

At the other end of the scale sits the Stalon XE149, the largest and most efficient moderator in the Stalon range and the one built with magnum calibres in mind. Its party trick is the telescopic XE rear section, which slides back over the barrel. The result is a moderator 311mm long overall that extends just 149mm beyond the muzzle, keeping the rifle’s length manageable and its weight nearer the shooter’s hands.

The pay-off is a claimed 34.5dB reduction, the highest figure quoted by any maker in this group. The body is anodised aluminium and 49.1mm in diameter, and it weighs 428g – the heaviest here, though well carried thanks to that over-barrel layout. Versions run from .204 up through .243, 6.5mm and .308, with a wide choice of threads. For the stalker using a bigger calibre from a high seat or on the hill, it is hard to beat.

gmk.co.uk

How do the five sound moderators compare?

Moderator Price Claimed reduction Best for
Ase Utra ECOi £55 29–33dB (rifle) No-fuss rabbiting with a .22
Hausken MD35 Mini £108 20dB or more A compact first moderator for a rimfire
Wildcat Panther £220 Not stated One moderator for a .22LR and a .22 Hornet
Freyr & Devik Featherweight 149 £330 27–29dB The stalker who covers miles on the hill
Stalon XE149 £380 34.5dB Magnum and bigger centrefire calibres

Frequently asked questions

Does a sound moderator need to go on my firearm certificate?

No. A moderator no longer needs to go on your certificate, but you must hold a firearm or shotgun certificate to possess one for a section 1 rifle.

What is an over-barrel sound moderator?

An over-barrel moderator has part of its body sitting back over the barrel, so it adds less length at the muzzle and keeps the weight nearer the shooter’s hands. The Wildcat Panther adds just 98mm at the muzzle, and the Stalon XE149 is 311mm long but extends only 149mm beyond it.

Which of the five is the quietest?

The Stalon XE149 claims a 34.5dB reduction, the highest figure quoted by any maker in this group.

What is the cheapest moderator here?

The Ase Utra ECOi rimfire moderator, at £55.

WinAlex Payne, James Haskell and Mike Tindall of The Good, The Bad and The Rugby podcastCloses 15 JanuaryWorth £129.90Win a pair of tickets to the British Shooting Show 2027Enter nowFree to enter

Related Articles