Home / News / Moorland Association opens draft Defra gamebird response to members

Moorland Association opens draft Defra gamebird response to members

Members have until 16 October to correct or add to the draft, with a Zoom briefing on 30 September and two guides for estates and beaters on submitting their own evidence

Grouse flying on a moorland
Estate records such as grouse counts and bags are the evidence Defra has asked for

The draft, published on 22 September with an evidence schedule setting out what each source shows and where it is limited, deals with wild red grouse and the management of England’s uplands rather than the rearing and release of pheasants, partridges and mallard. The association says it is not yet the final submission and wants members to tell it where the document has missed evidence, misread practice on the ground or failed to explain something clearly.

What does the draft ask Defra to do?

The response asks the department to look at what the evidence shows about individual management practices and their outcomes, rather than treating grouse shooting as a single environmental pressure. It sets out six tests: assess practices and measured outcomes, consider what would happen if the existing management system changed or ceased, recognise uncertainty and conflicting evidence, deal with demonstrated problems proportionately, weigh the wider consequences of change for management, jobs and conservation investment, and make the weighing of evidence open and checkable.

The draft does not pretend the evidence runs one way. It accepts there is “credible evidence of adverse impacts associated with some practices and of illegal killing and other offences against birds of prey”, alongside experimental and observational evidence of positive outcomes for ground-nesting birds and upland habitats.

Grouse are wild birds, not released stock

Red grouse are neither bred, reared nor released, and the association argues that evidence about grouse moors must be kept apart from evidence about released gamebirds. The evidence schedule published alongside the draft grades each source by type, from peer-reviewed experiments and government reviews to practitioner surveys and estate records, and says the same weighting should apply to evidence that challenges grouse-moor management as to evidence that supports it.

How can estates and beaters submit their own evidence?

Two practical guides were published the same day. One is for moor owners and managers who hold bird counts, habitat and peat restoration records, SSSI consents, grouse counts and bags or wildfire records. The other is for Guns, beaters, flankers, pickers-up, dog handlers, farmers and contractors, and points them to Question 29 of Defra’s call, which asks about recreational and social benefits.

The association is explicit that the aim is “not to generate identical submissions or general expressions of support for grouse shooting”, and the participant guide warns against second-hand stories and claims that go beyond what the evidence can show. Responses go through Defra’s online survey or by email, and the association will run a members’ Zoom briefing at 6pm on 30 September.

What happens next

Comments, corrections and additional evidence on the draft are due with the association by Friday 16 October, ahead of the final submission. Defra’s call for evidence closes at midnight on 1 November, and the department has said late responses will not be analysed. The draft, the evidence schedule and both guides are on the Moorland Association website.

Frequently asked questions

When does the Moorland Association want comments on its draft?

By Friday 16 October 2026, so they can be considered before the final submission goes to Defra ahead of the 1 November deadline.

Can beaters and pickers-up respond to Defra’s call for evidence?

Yes. The association’s participant guide explains how first-hand experience of beating, picking-up or working dogs on a moor can be presented as evidence, most usefully under Question 29 on recreational and social benefits.

When is the Moorland Association’s Zoom briefing?

At 6pm on 30 September 2026, for members preparing their own submissions; registration is through the association’s website.

WinAlex Payne, James Haskell and Mike Tindall of The Good, The Bad and The Rugby podcastCloses 15 JanuaryWorth £129.90Win a pair of tickets to the British Shooting Show 2027Enter nowFree to enter

Related Articles