Which gundog breed would suit all of my needs best?

Your sporting interests cover quite a wide range of gundog skills. A good cocker spaniel from working stock will make an excellent beating and roughshooting dog and it will have the ability, if correctly trained, to retrieve all types of quarry including geese, though a lively cripple could cause some difficulty.

If, however, your wildfowling is going to require a much stronger dog, a well-bred Labrador would be the obvious choice.

I live in the Fens and there are probably as many Labradors used for flushing in the beating line as spaniels, so don’t rule them out as all-rounders. The English springer has traditionally been described as the “maid of all work”, reputed to be larger than its smaller cousin the cocker, though in the modern day this is not always true. If your heart is set on a particular breed and it can fulfil the requirements of your sport, go with your instinct. It is much easier to train a breed of dog that you have a liking for and affinity with, than one you have been persuaded by others to get.